Common Mistakes When Owning Multiple Investment Properties

Adding a second or third property changes how lenders assess you. Here are the slip-ups Cannon Hill investors can avoid.

Hero Image for Common Mistakes When Owning Multiple Investment Properties

Most of the trouble with a growing portfolio comes from assuming each new loan will be assessed like the first one. It won't. Every extra property changes your debts, your income picture and the tax rules that apply to you.

If you're a Cannon Hill investor weighing up a second or third purchase, the aim is to know how a lender will see you before you apply. Here are the mistakes we see most often, and how to steer around them.

Why Do Lenders Count Only Part of Your Rental Income?

Lenders generally count no more than 80% of expected rent when they assess an investment loan. APRA's guidance says prudent policies apply a minimum 20% haircut to allow for periods when the property is empty. That haircut is separate from agent fees, repairs and other holding costs.

So a property that looks like it pays for itself on a spreadsheet may look weaker to a lender. Rental appraisals for a property you're about to buy are also usually given less weight than actual rent received. When you're mapping out your next purchase, use 80% of the rent as your working figure. Our borrowing capacity page is a good place to see how your income and debts fit together.

Does an Interest-Only Loan Let You Borrow More?

No. Choosing interest only does not raise your borrowing power, and it can reduce it. For interest-only loans, lenders are expected to test whether you can afford principal and interest repayments over the remaining term, after the interest-only period ends.

As an example, take a $500,000 investment loan at an illustrative 6.75% p.a. Interest only costs about $2,813 a month. The same loan on principal and interest over 30 years costs about $3,243 a month. If you take five years of interest only, the repayment then jumps to about $3,455 a month, because the principal has to be paid off over the remaining 25 years.

Interest only keeps your repayments lower early on and can help with cash flow across several properties. The trade-off is that the loan balance doesn't fall during that time, and the later repayments are higher. Use a repayment calculator to check both versions before you choose. Our investment loans page covers the structures available.

How Does Negative Gearing Work for a Second or Third Property?

The tax treatment of a rental loss now depends on when you bought the property. Losses from residential investment properties held at 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 continue to be deductible against your other income, including your salary. The same applies to eligible new builds acquired after that date.

For established properties bought after that time, the rules change from the 2027-28 income year. Net rental losses can then be used only against other residential property income, including residential capital gains, and unused losses carry forward. Between 12 May 2026 and 30 June 2027, the current rules apply until 30 June 2027 only.

This matters if you're adding to a portfolio, because the date you buy and whether the property is an established or new dwelling can change how much a loss is worth to you. These rules are complex, and the right answer depends on your own situation, so speak to your accountant before you commit.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at LBK Lending today.

Can You Use Equity From One Property to Buy Another?

Yes, many investors use equity in one property as the deposit for the next, but the way you use the money decides whether the interest is deductible. The ATO looks at what the borrowed funds are actually used for, not just which property secures the loan.

Consider an investor who has built up equity in their first rental and wants to buy a second. They split the borrowing into a separate loan for the investment purchase, and keep any money used for personal costs apart from it. At tax time, the interest on the investment portion is clear to identify, and the accountant can work out the deductible part. Mixing in a holiday or renovation on the family home would have blurred that line, because interest on funds used privately is not deductible.

The trade-off is that you're taking on more debt secured against property you already own. Lenders also set their own limits on how far above 80% of a property's value you can go, and borrowing above that level generally means paying lenders mortgage insurance. Again, check the tax detail with your accountant.

Do All Lenders Assess Multiple Properties the Same Way?

No. Banks, credit unions and building societies are subject to APRA rules, including a serviceability buffer of 3 percentage points above the loan rate. They also face a portfolio-level limit on high debt-to-income lending. Non-bank lenders are not covered by those particular requirements.

That limit applies to each lender's overall new lending, not to you personally, so each lender decides your application under its own credit policy. Policies differ on things like how rental income is treated, how much existing debt counts against you, and how far you can borrow against your properties. A lender that suits your first purchase may not suit your third.

That's where a broker earns their keep. We can compare the lenders on our panel, and check whether it's worth looking at refinancing an older loan to release room. A loan health check is a good way to see where your existing loans sit before you apply.

Why Should You Plan Your Loan Structure Before You Buy?

Setting up your loans before you buy gives you more choices once you've found a property. Changing a loan structure during a purchase can be difficult and depends on the lender.

Before you start looking, work out your deposit, your likely repayments at a rate higher than today's, and what buffer you'd hold if a property sat empty for a while. Ask how a new loan would affect your other lending. Also ask how an offset account would change the interest you pay and therefore your deductions, because it lowers the interest charged on the loan.

A conversation up front often saves weeks later, and it keeps your options open if a good property comes up.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much rental income do lenders count on an investment property?

Lenders generally count no more than 80% of expected rent. This allows for periods when the property is not rented. Each lender sets its own policy on the rest.

Does interest only increase how much I can borrow?

No. Lenders are expected to assess your ability to repay principal and interest over the remaining term after the interest-only period. This can lower, not raise, your borrowing power.

Is interest on money borrowed against my property always tax deductible?

No. Deductibility depends on how the borrowed funds are used. Interest on money used for private purposes is not deductible, so speak to your accountant.

Have negative gearing rules changed for new investment purchases?

Yes. From the 2027-28 income year, losses on established residential properties bought after 12 May 2026 can generally only be used against residential property income. Your accountant can explain how this applies to you.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at LBK Lending today.